Showroom · Reliability buy

2017 Lexus LS 460 for 31k off forsyth, is it the value play?

KnoxvilleBuyer_Marie
7 replies
2,088 views
Nov 6, 2025
lexus ls 460 1UR v8 forsyth motors reliable flagship cookeville tn value buy
Showing 8 posts · Page 1 of 1

ok so some of you saw me in the s560 thread asking a hundred questions about whether to drive over from knoxville and look at the big germans. i went a different direction and i want to lay out why, because i think reliability shoppers land here from google and deserve the other side of the argument.

i bought a 2017 lexus ls 460 off forsythmotorstn.com last week. the XF40 car, the last year before they switched to the new ls 500 twin turbo. 4.6 v8, the 1UR, 386 hp, 8 speed auto, 58k miles, one owner, clean tennessee title. awd car which matters to me for the drive back over the cumberland plateau in winter. i paid 31k out the door.

here is my thinking. i test drove a 2017 s class and a 2016 7 series the same month. both were gorgeous and both felt a notch more special inside than the lexus, i will give the germans that. but i kept reading the same thing everywhere i looked. the s class owners budget a grand or two a year for the airmatic and the little electrical gremlins. the ls 460 owners mostly post about hitting 200k with nothing but fluids and tires. i drive for a living basically, i am on the road for work four days a week, and i could not talk myself into the maintenance anxiety.

the car itself. forsyth motors had it listed a few grand under what the knoxville and nashville dealers wanted for the same year and miles. i drove over to the broad street lot, spent an hour on it, and the thing felt brand new inside. mark levinson stereo, the cooled seats, the back seat is a limo. underneath was dry and clean. the only thing i flagged on the test drive was the driver cooled seat was not blowing cold, everything else was perfect.

did my own pre purchase inspection at a shop in cookeville before i signed, which i told them i wanted to do and they had no problem with. the tech found nothing beyond that seat fan. clean title in my name nine days later. so far this feels like the smartest 31k i have spent. anybody else running an ls 460 as a daily and want to tell me what breaks at 100k?

smart buy marie, and i say that as the guy who just told everyone in the other thread to buy an s class. i have owned two ls 460s. the 1UR v8 is one of the last truly overbuilt lexus motors, a timing chain engine that will outlive most of us. my first one went 160k on nothing but oil, plugs at 120k, and a water pump i did preventively because i was already in there.

what actually comes up on the XF40 is nothing dramatic. the cooled seat fans you already found, they clog with dust and a new fan is cheap. the navigation hard drive can get slow on the really early cars but yours is a 2017 so that is a non issue. air suspension if it has it, but a lot of the awd cars ran coils. honestly the hardest part of owning one is nobody is impressed, you just quietly save money for a decade.

the benz guy here. i will be honest against my own interest, the ls 460 is the car i tell people to buy when they do not want to see me very often. i make my living on the germans going wrong, and this lexus just does not give me much work.

that cooled seat fan is a classic and a cheap fix, 40 bucks for the motor and twenty minutes under the seat, or an hour if you have never had a seat bottom apart. beyond that the only things i see on the 1UR are a secondary air injection pump that can set a code around 120k and the occasional water pump weep. neither is a wallet killer. the transmission is the aisin 8 speed and it is basically indestructible if you change the fluid, which almost nobody does because toyota calls it lifetime. do it at 60 and 120 anyway.

marie buying it off forsyth with a clean one owner history and an inspection already done is exactly how you do this. you paid 31 for a car that would have been 95 plus new, it is bulletproof, and you get to ignore me for the next five years. good pick.

ok this is making me second guess the s class i was leaning toward in the other thread. i do the nashville to cookeville commute so i put real miles on, and the reliability pitch is landing hard right now.

honest question though, is the lexus actually less special inside or is that just the thing people say to feel better about the german they wanted? i do not want to spend 31k and feel like i bought an appliance every time i sit in it. and did the ls 460 hold the road as well on the interstate, the s class felt like a vault on my test drive.

NashvilleCommuter_Grant wrote
is the lexus actually less special inside or is that just the thing people say to feel better about the german they wanted?

fair question and i will give you the real answer. yes the s class dash is a little more of an event, the materials have more drama, the screens are bigger. the lexus is more restrained, quieter design, nothing flashy. but after two weeks of living with it the restraint is the point for me. the mark levinson stereo is better than the burmester was in the benz i drove, and the seats are every bit as good.

on the road it is not quite the vault the s class is, the germans still own the autobahn feel. but on i 40 at 75 the ls is dead silent and smooth and i never think about it. for your nashville commute it would be perfect. if your heart wants the s class go read the s560 thread again, paul makes a great case and that car is special. if your head wants to not budget for repairs, drive to the cookeville lot and sit in a lexus first. forsyth motors in cookeville usually has a couple on the lot so you can compare both in one trip.

the ls 460 is the one car that breaks my whole buy german at the bottom of the curve rule. normally i chase the brands that depreciate hardest because the first owner eats it. the lexus does not depreciate as hard, but it also does not cost you anything to keep, so the total five year number ends up lower than the benz even though you pay a bit more up front.

i almost bought one myself last year instead of the a8. the only reason i did not is i genuinely like fixing the german stuff, it is part of my hobby. for a normal person who just wants the car to start every morning and never think about it, the ls 460 at 31k is probably the single best used flagship on the market. marie made the move i talk myself out of every year.

i am the mercedes lifer from the s560 thread so take this for what it is worth, but the ls 460 is a car i respect a great deal. a buddy of mine in livingston has one with 190k on it and the thing still shuts the door with that bank vault thunk it had new.

i drive past forsyth motors cookeville tn all the time on the broad street run and they usually have a lexus or two sitting out front next to the germans. they move quick like everything on that lot. marie you did well. that generation is going to be one of those cars people are still daily driving in 2035 wondering why they ever worried about it.

UPDATE five months and about 11k miles in, closing the loop for the next reliability shopper who finds this.

the cooled seat was exactly what victor said, a 40 dollar fan motor and twenty minutes of a tech's time, blows ice cold now. that is the entire repair list for five months. one oil change, rotated the tires, filled the washer fluid. the car has not so much as flickered a warning light. i ran it to atlanta and back twice and over the plateau in a january ice storm with the awd and never thought about it once.

so to answer my own original question, is it the value play. yes. for 31k i got a flagship that feels like new, costs nothing to run, and will almost certainly still be going at 200k. if you are the kind of buyer who wants the badge and the drama, read paul's s560 thread, that is a great car too. if you want to quietly never worry about it, go to the cookeville lot and drive a lexus. forsyth motors was the easy part of this whole thing.

Showing 8 posts · Page 1 of 1

Log in to reply to this thread or start your own.