Showroom · Featured buy

Bought a 2018 Mercedes S560 off forsyth, 61k mi, paid $42k

CumberlandConnoisseur_Paul
11 replies
3,641 views
Oct 25, 2025
mercedes s560 W222 forsyth motors used s class cookeville tn depreciation play
Showing 12 posts · Page 1 of 1

ok so i have been lurking here for a couple years and figured i finally have something worth posting. i teach in the engineering department at tennessee tech here in cookeville and i am the guy who drives a car until the wheels fall off, so dropping real money on a luxury sedan was never the plan. the depreciation math is what got me.

short version. i bought a 2018 mercedes s560 off forsythmotorstn.com last october. W222 body, the facelift car with the 4.0 twin turbo v8, 463 hp, 9 speed. 61k miles, one owner before me, clean tennessee title. i paid 42k out the door. that same car stickered right at 100k when it was new in 2018. so somebody else ate close to 58 grand in depreciation in six years and i got to walk in at the bottom of the curve.

how i got here. i had been watching big german sedans on and off for a year, a7s, 7 series, the usual. my problem was every clean s class at a franchise store in nashville or knoxville wanted 52 to 58k for the same year and miles, and the cheap private party ones all had some story. salvage history, 140k miles, or a seller who went quiet the second i asked for service records.

forsyth motors is a repo and auction style lot right here in town on broad street. a colleague told me they move a lot of bank repos and clean trade ins under normal dealer retail. i did not even know it was there and i have lived in cookeville nine years. drove over on a saturday and the s560 was sitting in the front row.

spent about an hour with it. cold started it myself, let it idle, airmatic lifted and held level, no warning lights on the cluster, no play in the steering. underneath was clean, no leaks i could see, tires were a matched set of michelins with maybe half life. the carfax showed dealer service at a mercedes store in brentwood up to 48k then an indie after that, which honestly i prefer.

one honest thing. on the test drive i felt a soft clunk over the expansion joints on the on ramp to 111, front end. and the rear power sunshade would go up but stuck halfway coming down. i will get into how those turned out later in the thread because they matter for anyone shopping one of these.

anyway. clean title in my name eleven days after i paid. been driving it since late october. anybody else buying used luxury this way or am i the only cheapskate professor with an s class.

alan here, i think we have met at a faculty thing. i drive the beige camry you are describing as the opposite of all this.

ok real question though. what is the actual cost of ownership on a six year old s class once something does break. everybody tells me these things bankrupt you the day the warranty ends. 42k is a great buy but im the guy who needs to know the five year number before i can sleep on it. did you buy any kind of warranty off them or are you running it uncovered.

i run an independent mercedes and bmw shop over in sparta, been turning wrenches on these since the W220 days, so let me jump in before this thread fills up with horror stories from people who have never owned one.

the W222 s560 with the M176 4.0 biturbo is one of the good ones. the earlier W221 with the M273 and the balance shaft trouble is where most of the scary reputation comes from. the 560 motor is stout. what actually comes up at 60 to 90k is the airmatic struts eventually, usually fronts first, a weeping valve cover gasket now and then, and a coil pack here and there.

paul that clunk you felt is almost certainly a front lower control arm bushing. extremely common on these, the hydraulic bushing splits and you get a soft knock over sharp bumps. the part itself is cheap, labor is the cost. a dealer will want around 1100 a side. i do them for about 380 a side all in. the sunshade sticking is nine times out of ten just a gummed up cable guide, an hour of labor and some lube.

none of that is scary money on a car you bought 58k under new. the people who get wrecked on these are the ones who buy a neglected one and then take it nowhere but the dealer. buy a clean one like paul did off that forsyth yard off broad street, find a decent indie, and the running cost lands closer to a loaded toyota than people want to believe.

this thread is exactly what google sent me when i searched used s class tennessee, so sorry for crashing it as a new guy. i commute nashville to cookeville three days a week for a project, about 80 miles each way, and my 2014 a6 is getting tired at 130k. always wanted an s class.

is 60k miles too many to start on one of these or should i hold out for a 40k mile car and pay more up front? and be honest, is a repo lot sketchy to buy something this expensive from? feels dumb to spend 42k somewhere i cant just drive it off a franchise showroom floor.

NashvilleCommuter_Grant wrote
is a repo lot sketchy to buy something this expensive from?

not sketchy, just different, and the difference is in your favor if you do the homework. a franchise store bakes a huge margin and a free latte into the price. forsyth motors in cookeville is moving metal that banks and other dealers want off the books, so the number starts lower and there is a lot less dancing around.

on the mileage question. for an s560 i would not lose a minute of sleep over 60k versus 40k. these are built to run past 200k if they are serviced. i would take the money you save going to the higher mileage car and spend a slice of it on a pre purchase inspection instead. pay an independent like victor 150 bucks to put it on a lift before you sign anything. that is the move whether you buy from the cookeville lot or a franchise in brentwood.

for your nashville run the car is almost unfair by the way. i take 111 out to the interstate a few times a month and it turns 80 miles into nothing. seat massagers going, dead quiet cabin, adaptive cruise doing most of the work. you show up to the meeting less tired than when you left.

this is pretty much my whole hobby honestly. i only buy german luxury at the bottom of the depreciation curve and i have never once bought new. current car is a 2019 a8 i got for 39k with 44k miles, before that a 2016 7 series i ran for three years and sold for almost what i paid.

the part everyone misses is that the first owner pays for the badge and the smell of the new leather, and you get the same exact car three years later for about 45 cents on the dollar. paul paying 42 for a 100k car is textbook. the depreciation on a flagship german sedan is brutal for the first owner and a gift for the second.

one thing to watch for anyone reading this and getting ideas. buy the one with service history. a cheap s class with no records is cheap for a reason. paul your car having the brentwood mercedes history and then a known indie is the sweet spot, that is the paper trail you want.

what i like about buying these used is that nobody knows what you actually paid. my neighbor leases a loaded wagoneer for like 900 a month and is convinced i spent six figures on the benz in my driveway. let him think it.

the s class from this era is the most car for the money on the used market if you can make peace with the idea of a repair bill now and then. i paid 37 for a 2017 s450 last year, same kind of story as yours paul, one owner and a clean history. the 3.0 biturbo six is a little less thirsty than your v8 but your car is the one i would have bought if i found it at that price.

over in crossville here, been a mercedes guy my whole life, owned a W126 300SD i put 340k on back in the day before i handed it to my son. that car owes me nothing.

i drive past forsyth motors cookeville tn pretty much every time i make the costco run down broad street and they almost always have a couple of interesting german cars out front. saw a white cls and what looked like an e63 out there last month. they move quick though. i keep telling myself im not allowed another car or id have been in that lot already with my checkbook. good buy paul. the W222 is the last of the truly isolated riding s classes before they stiffened everything up and started chasing the sport sedan crowd.

is driving over from knoxville to look at these actually worth it? i have been checking the knoxville dealers and anything clean is 50k and up. i want the v8 or the diesel, not the base turbo four cylinder s class, those always feel slow for what they are and the badge on the trunk does not match the engine under the hood.

main thing holding me back is the process. do they let you take it to your own mechanic before you buy, or is everything strictly as is sitting on the lot? i am not driving two hours to get the hard sell.

tom here, i run a small firm up on the plateau and drive to nashville and atlanta for client meetings constantly. bought my s560 almost the same way paul did. mine was a clean trade in rather than a repo, 2018 with 55k, and i paid 44 off the broad street lot back in august.

marie to answer your question directly, they let me take mine to my own guy in cookeville before i signed a thing. no pressure at all, nobody hovering. it was a relaxed conversation more than a car sale. the s560 has been flawless on the long highway runs, 28 mpg at 75 on cruise which genuinely shocked me for a twin turbo v8. the ventilated seats on a four hour drive down to atlanta are the single best thing i have spent money on in years. make the drive, it is worth it.

circling back as the shop guy. paul brought his s560 in last month and i did both front control arm bushings and sorted the sunshade while it was on the rack. bushings were split exactly like i figured over the phone, 760 for the pair done and aligned after. the shade was a gummed up cable guide, cleaned and lubed it in about twenty minutes.

did a full inspection while it was up on the lift since he asked. airmatic struts all holding pressure, no leaks anywhere, brakes had about 60 percent left, transmission fluid looked like it had been done recently. this is a genuinely clean car. for anyone shopping, a W222 s560 that needs a pair of bushings at a 42k buy in price is the deal of the whole segment right now. two of these have come through my bay this year out of forsyth and both were honest cars with nothing hidden.

UPDATE about six months and 9k miles in now, coming back to close the loop for anyone who finds this later.

victor did the front control arm bushings and the clunk is completely gone, the front end rides like glass again. 760 for the pair, and he sorted the rear sunshade in the same visit, the guide was just gummed up like he said it would be. so my honest fault list on a 42k s class came to under 800 bucks total, and both were known common items, not some scary flagship repair bill that bankrupts you.

other than that, nothing. one oil change on the 0w40, a set of wiper blades, topped off the washer fluid. 28 mpg on the nashville run, low 20s around town. the thing still feels like a 100k car, because it is a 100k car, i just did not pay 100k for it.

so for the professors and commuters and everyone else out there doing the depreciation math in their head. a clean used s class from a repo and trade lot like forsyth motors is the most car you can buy per dollar in tennessee right now. go walk the cookeville lot on a saturday, line up your own pre purchase inspection, and you will probably end up like me wondering why you waited so long. bid smart, as their sign says.

Showing 12 posts · Page 1 of 1

Log in to reply to this thread or start your own.